TreadOnMe [none/use name]

  • 0 Posts
  • 1.27K Comments
Joined 5 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 24th, 2020

help-circle










  • This is extremely reactionary thinking. China does a thing, therefore it is in crisis!

    How is this anything like Bonapartism? Bonaparte was a military general who used the chaos of revolution to consolidate power under a completely reformed army (that he wasn’t responsible for) to solidify his own authority, which came out of the absence and deferment of leadership from the unpopular central government, who had, in typical liberal fashion, purged themselves (violently this time around) of the ability to actually do anything.

    This is literally the exact opposite thing. The central civilian government is using its currently extremely popular position to purge the military of its elderly members and allow new blood up through the ranks. It is not healthy for 70 year olds who have never actually fought a real war since Vietnam (where they lost btw) to be in charge of a military that is increasingly becoming the second most technologically advanced military in the world, even surpassing the U.S. in some technical capabilities. This is not a sign of crisis. This is a sign of the strength of the civilian government to be able to audit the military and bring it under control.

    The idea that Xi hasn’t cemented himself in the legacy of Chinese government with his massive anti-corruption pushes and green energy initiatives is completely out of touch with the reality within China and Chinese culture.

    Unless some new young general comes in and begins to centralize power around himself through military conquest, these comparisons are silly and historically illiterate.




  • The CDC primarily measured average COVID cases through waste contamination tests, not hospitals testing and reporting numbers. If you cut the funding for those tests to the CDC then yeah, they aren’t going to do the sewage tests to measure the rates. No such thing has happened for the NYPD.

    Crime rates usually come from the incident reports filed directly by police officers. In a healthy policing scenario, most of these incident reports are created from someone calling or notifying the police about something going on, not from them just stumbling onto something.

    If anything may this indicate that police were purposely instigating and escalating incidents, depending on what the percentages of “community instigated incidents” are. It could also just mean that it is fucking cold outside and people just aren’t doing shit at all. These numbers don’t really mean anything without a hell of a lot of extra context.

    However, the statistical relationship between an increase in policing and a decrease in crime has always been tenuous, at best.