Hello and good evening self hosters! so i recently new to self hosting, i just installed my CM3588 DIY NAS with a bunch of services which is very addicting!

but i digress, so i recently found out today that we pay $11 a month to rent our router for our house. Which i personally think is ridiculous! So i am looking into buying to own, not renting to burn money. However the router seems to get internet from the ISP through moCA which looking at router that support moCA are rather limiting in speeds and very expensive. So my query for this fine, fine community is if i were to buy a coax/moCA adapter that then coverts it to Ethernet and then plug it into my router and and then by proxy my access points. would it work, wifi 6E looks super nice and there are very few options that are very pricey for modem/router combos that support moCA.

I am open to alternatives and ideas, and please correct me if i made any mistakes on terminally or my diagram

thanks folks!

Edit— my current router is a ARRIS Surfboard TG3452 DOCSIS 3.1 Cable Voice Gateway Modem Router with 802.11ac Wi-Fi & MoCA 2.0

So

  • Onno (VK6FLAB)English
    48·
    7 months ago

    Before spending any time or money on this, I’d ask my ISP if you are allowed to bring your own hardware and what type of support is available in that scenario.

    Before you make that call, another thing to consider is that $11 per month is paying for two things, not just the hardware, but the associated support which allows you to say: “Sorry, the internet is down and it’s your hardware.”

    Finally, most network hardware costs in the order of $500 or more. It regularly fails around the three year mark, when it’s out of warranty. In your situation, that’s not your problem, since it’s their hardware.

    So, for me, it seems like a no-brainer to stay where you are, but I’m not you and you might have different requirements.

    I for one work from home and I need my network to be reliable.

    • mipadaitu@lemmy.worldEnglish
      3·
      7 months ago

      Nah, a cable modem costs anywhere from $60-$300 depending on if you want one with a built in router/wifi. That’s a pretty good return on investment. Mine has been running just fine for over a decade, and I’ve replaced the wifi router behind it 3 times to get improvements in WiFI speed that I wouldn’t have gotten from my ISP. $11/mo would have cost me an extra $1,300+ of fees by now.

      I have mediacom, and they’re pretty good about support in my area, even if they are pretty shitty about other things. They can and do send signals to be able to manage a self-owned cable modem, and they’ll send a tech to your house and diagnose issues, even if you roll your own network.

      The US has some decent laws around protecting you from getting shafted by ISPs for this specific situation.
      https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/03/router-and-modem-rental-fees-still-a-major-annoyance-despite-new-us-law/

      • Onno (VK6FLAB)English
        1·
        7 months ago

        That’s very interesting. Nothing like that exists in Australia as far as I know.

        You can bring your own hardware and take your chances with support, or you can get a modem from the ISP when you sign up.

        Depending on the situation, I’ve done both.